Skip to content

New Article - Almost Is Not Nothing: The All-Or-Nothing Error From Plato To "Almost Persuaded"

Today added to the site is a new ethics article on the all-or-nothing error.

A nineteenth-century hymn warns that "'Almost' is but to fail." Behind it stands a line of thought that runs from Plato's Philebus, through the Stoic doctrine that all faults are equal, to the theology that all have sinned and come short of the glory of God. Even the early Church Fathers knew that "all sins are equal" was a Stoic absurdity. The common thread is a standard of perfection set outside this world, against which every human distance becomes the same distance.

The article shows how that one error corrupts our ideas of goodness, happiness, knowledge, progress, justice, and divinity, and above all pleasure, where it leads to the false conclusion that pleasure has no real degrees and that the only pleasure worth having is complete absence of pain. It then sets out Epicurus' answer, and explains why the limit of pleasure does not make lesser degrees worthless. As Torquatus says of the wise man, pains never prevent him "from finding more reasons for joy than for vexation."

The article can be read at the link below or by opening the "Ethics Analysis" menu in the left navigation sidebar.

Almost Is Not Nothing