Skip to content

New Article - Duty Without Pleasure: An Epicurean Analysis Of Cicero's On Duties

Today added to the site is a new article analyzing Cicero's On Duties from the Epicurean point of view.

On Duties became one of the most widely read books of moral instruction in Europe, and it was written to shut out Epicurus. Cicero asks his son to accept his key premise the way a mathematician accepts an axiom, and he treats pleasure as the pleasure of beasts. But read closely, the book borrows Epicurus' arguments. Cicero admits that duty changes "with a change of expediency," proves that justice pays because injustice brings fear and hatred, and grants that gods are never angry.

The article also takes up the famous case of the grain merchant of Rhodes, where Cicero's answer is stricter than that of Thomas Aquinas. As the American jurist James Kent put it, "It is a little singular, however, that some of the best ethical writers under the Christian dispensation, should complain of the moral lessons of Cicero as being too austere in their texture." The article shows how an Epicurean would decide the case, and answers each of Cicero's final charges against Epicurus.

The article can be read at the link below or by opening the "Other Analysis" menu in the left navigation sidebar.

Duty Without Pleasure: An Epicurean Analysis Of Cicero's On Duties