Skip to content

New Article and Updated Page - Philodemus' On Methods Of Inference

Today added to the site is a new canonics article on Philodemus' On Methods of Inference, often called On Signs, together with a rebuilt page for the text itself.

On Methods of Inference is the fullest surviving Epicurean account of how we know what we cannot see: atoms, void, other worlds, and the nature of divine beings. Stoic critics argued that only a formal test of logic can give certain knowledge. The Epicureans answered that the formal test itself rests on what we have observed: "If the method of analogy is not cogent, the method of contraposition is not cogent." They argued that unique cases like the magnet support reasoning by analogy, that the limits we see in nature make it safe to reason from the seen to the unseen, and that knowledge is real without being all or nothing: "certainty and probability are both derived from the observation of appearances."

The text page now has Phillip and Estelle De Lacy's 1941 translation checked against the printed volume, an anchor for every column of the papyrus, page links to the scanned book, an Epicurean guide and outline, De Lacy's full introduction, and his supplementary chapters on the life of Philodemus, the sources of Epicurean empiricism, the development of Epicurean logic, and the controversies of the Stoics, Epicureans, and Sceptics, with his bibliography.

The article can be read at the first link below or by opening the "Canonics Analysis" menu in the left navigation sidebar. The text is under "Philodemus - On Signs" in the source menus.

Reasoning From What We See To What We Cannot

Philodemus, On Methods of Inference (De Lacy)